Once Upon a River: Book Review by Asha Seth

Review Available on: InstagramGoodreads | Amazon

Author: Diane Setterfield| Genre: Fantasy | Pages: 464

The Blurb:

On a dark midwinter’s night in an ancient inn on the river Thames, an extraordinary event takes place. The regulars are telling stories to while away the dark hours, when the door bursts open on a grievously wounded stranger. In his arms is the lifeless body of a small child. Hours later, the girl stirs, takes a breath and returns to life. Is it a miracle? Is it magic? Or can science provide an explanation? These questions have many answers, some of them quite dark indeed.

diane setterfield once upon a river book review asha seth badbookthief
Image Copyright: Asha Seth

The Review:

More than once I was swept by the notion that the true protagonist of the story was the river Thames itself. And here’s why,

Every year the river helps herself to a few lives. One drink too many, one hasty step, one second’s lapse of attention is all it takes.

When Joe’s eyes returned to the room, he was ready and opened his mouth to speak.
‘Once upon a time—-‘
The door opened.

And begins the story of the dead girl who was later alive. Also that of the Vaughan couple, the Armstrong household, Daunt – the photographer, Rita – the nurse, Lily – the parsonage maid, Ruby – the Vaughan’s baby-sitter, and most importantly, the Ockwells of the Swan Inn.

Upon the heart of Thames, is the Swam Inn known for its story-telling folks, but everything changes on the long winter night when a stranger intrudes the story-telling aura of the inn, with a drowned child in his arms and thereafter collapses into unconsciousness, with his body a picture of bruises.

Nobody knows who the girl is, who was dead a while ago, and has come to life, quite shocking to the folks present. It is considered a miracle, one, the villagers have never witnessed. Thereupon, people from far and wide come forward laying a claim upon the girl, revealing their darkest secrets in the process.

The Vaughan’s have lost their only daughter, about the same age, two years back. The Armstrongs put a claim to her name after their wayward son Robin abandons his wife and daughter and resorts to low means of living through trickery, thieving, and the likes. Lily believes the girl to be her sister Ann, who died of mysterious circumstances in childhood, and who has come back from the dead.

Rita, Daunt, and several other people at the Swan, who have laid eyes on the girl, drip of obvious temptation to raise the girl as their own child. Amidst a most tiresome chasing of the truth behind the mute child, unfolding of stories after stories of the several households in Bampton, Radcot, Buscot, Kelmskott, and Brandy Island, runs the magnificent, all-encompassing, all-pervading, incomprehensible, yet exceedingly alluring, the Thames.

The aura of the prose is as mysterious as the Thames itself, and the the building tension adds more intrigue where one would want to skip to the end to figure the girl’s tale. But my friend, that’s where Setterfield’s genius comes dancing to the surface because you are in for the most beguiling twist yet.

Unpredictable as the characters and the story is, one thing binds them all and that is the love for the girl which is truly intense and moving at times. I was moist-eyed as I came upon the Vaughan’s story and the lie draped truth they are living with.

There is no one central character because the plots keep flitting between the several subplots and one would think that the girl is central to the theme although there is no direct contribution from her to the story.

The book is perfect in all sense, except that it wasn’t anywhere close to ‘The Thirteenth Tale’. The writing was as beautiful as TTT, except it couldn’t stir the gentle waves inside of me that craved to be wrecked. Somewhere after 200 pages, the pace dulled down to a crawl and the characters could do only so much to keep you intrigued. It is an absolute masterpiece if you haven’t tasted the magic TTT is, and yet I couldn’t stop myself comparing knowing full well that it does not do justice as a reviewer.

Stories and stories and stories waited to jump at you at every corner, which proved once again, the prodigy that Setterfield is when it comes to story-telling. She truly is a master of the art, and yet somehow everything felt short of something, like an emptiness after you’re done reading, like a tickling void that even 450+ pages couldn’t completely fill. Is it good or bad, who can tell? All I know is I’m going to read this book again because Setterfield sure knows how to rope the reader in for years to come; because the spell won’t wear off that easy.

You can buy your copy of ‘Once Upon A River’ by clicking on this link.

Have you read ‘Once Upon A River’? How did you like it? Share your thoughts in comments below.

Happy reading till we meet next.

Until then, carpe diem! 🙂

~~~~~

© Asha Seth

Stay in touch.
Subscribe Now: Youtube| Twitter| Instagram| Facebook| Tumblr

12 Replies to “Once Upon a River: Book Review by Asha Seth”

  1. Marvelous review! I agree that I enjoyed The Thirteenth Tale more, but I also think they were slightly different genres, weren’t they? Or they felt like it to me. It felt like the tension was drawn out just a little too long for me in Once Upon a River, where I kept waiting for something to happen and it was like, “Not yet. Not yet. Not yet.” That being said, I did love this book, and the writing was beautiful, and it was truly an amazing use of magical realism. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you very much, Sammie, for catching up with the review. There was really a very fine line between the genres, and in a way, I found OUAR pretty close to TTT with the main plot wrapped around mysterious kids, obscure backgrounds of those kids, and some heart-wrenching tragedy at the heart of it all. The twist surely was well concealed and for that Setterfield gets full marks. That said, I was expecting much more from OUAR because of the benchmark TTT became for me. But not that I didn’t enjoy the latter book. I did very much. Yes!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Brilliant review, this sounds like a fantastic read – I will definitely have to give this one a go at some point! Beautifully written review! ❤ 😀

    Like

“I love writing. I love the swirl and swing of words as they tangle with human emotions.” ― James A. Michener

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: